Welcome
Philos Sophia
For the study of ancient Greek philosophy.

Socrates and Plato (7 threads, 95 posts)
    Plato: Epistemology (18 posts)
    Historical Thread

    Dialectics vs. Perception ...
    5 Members have made 18 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: Maximius
    Prev: Systematically Unsystematical?
    Epistemology or Not?
    ruoska.gif
    Author: * Maximius Flavius - 8 Posts on this thread out of 1,875 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Feb 2, 2003 - 17:35

    To answer the last clause in your post, Logicon, that is a tough question. Let me put it this way: before Descartes, philosophy and laymen alike had a bit different conception on the relationship of subject and object. Kantian philosophy couldn't have happened in the 1500's.

    The difference between Kant and Plato is that Kant is an "activist," he practises a critical theory.

    Plato - he started out with epistemology, it was the main feature throughout, in my opinion. He asked, first "What is good? What is evil?" and after that (for example, in Theaitetos): "What is knowledge?"

    And if that question is presented, it is epistemology after that! :-)

    But Plato's problem was not that our "forms of Anschauung" and "categories of Verstand" organise our sense perception - quite the contrary, he found sense perception fallible due to the fact it showed change, no clear limits, chaos. In addition to this, there was the question of how we use our (universal) concepts. And the "theory of ideas" is an answer, or a brilliant attempt to answer, both of these questions. Kant just thought we cannot ever separate, or "turn off," the elements of our mind.

    Don't you think?


    NEXT: Maximius
    PREV: Systematically Unsystematical?
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff