Welcome
Ex Libris
Reading is knowledge, it is escape, it is enjoyment. Here we will be discussing books, fiction and non.

Children’s Literature (3 threads, 486 posts)
    Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (SPOILERS) (127 posts)
    Social Thread 4 Featured July 16 , 2007

    A Place to discuss the last of the Harry Potter series. Do not read this topic until you have read Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. ...
    32 Members have made 125 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: Harry and Voldemort
    Prev: Re: Page differences
    Thoughts and musings
    library.jpg
    Author: * Merle Hammurabi - 5 Posts on this thread out of 17 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Jul 31, 2007 - 15:40

    So Harry really was related to Riddle. Just not a descendant of Slytherin, apparently. Peverells must have been a different part of Gaunt's geneology.

    I appreciate that Jo always intended Snape to be protecting Harry. However, my original prediction that Snape was acting on Voldemort's orders was based on literary considerations. I reasoned that for Snape to be acting on Dumbledore's orders, Jo would have to engage in some awkward exposition. Thus, The Prince's Tale.

    I found all the exposition in two of the final four chapters to be a bit awkward. Just MHO.

    Other than that small criticism, I really enjoyed how this turned out. We shouldn't be surprised that a bit of Voldemort's soul went into Harry, as Dumbledore had always hinted that this was so. He told Harry that he could speak parseltongue because V had given that power to him. I'd have to go back for more, but I think he even so much as said that V transferred a bit of himself to Harry, which clearly means "soul." Jo was playing a subtle linguistic game when she denied Harry was a horcrux. He had a bit of soul, but I guess he wasn't a horcrux per se, because V didn't do it intentionally. Hermione talked about a spell which must be performed to transfer a bit of soul to a horcrux, and clearly V didn't get to do that in Harry's case, because he was destroyed.

    I thought it appropriate that V met his downfall yet again because he didn't think things through. In the end, even Harry out thought him. Nice application of "pride goeth before a fall." I was immensely proud of Harry in that final confrontation in the Great Hall.


    NEXT: Harry and Voldemort
    PREV: Re: Page differences
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff