Welcome
The Ages of Bronze and Iron
A group dedicated to the study of the Aegean Late Bronze and Early Iron Ages.

Ages of Bronze & Iron: The Minoans (7 threads, 93 posts)
    The Minoans abroad (25 posts)
    Historical Thread

    Contacts between Minoan Crete and the Eastern Mediterranean. ...
    7 Members have made 25 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: Nation Building 1800 BC - Forget it!
    Prev: Excellent, I'll take a look!
    At the risk of exposing my inexpert head
    Dravidia.gif
    Author: * Dravidia CuChulainn - 3 Posts on this thread out of 1,086 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Oct 6, 2006 - 11:27

    once more to the axes of scholastic researchers, I have a question or two to pose, Demetrios.

    Do researchers consider the possibility that what they are viewing as discrete cultures may not have been anything of the kind? That, like modern-day peoples, they may have been so intermingled with each other that such classifications would have seemed totally out of left field to them? (For example: someone from another planet researching say, an extinct Russia, would find enormous differences between an inhabitant of a city like Moscow, and one from Siberia; yet both belong to the same nation.) And language and/or religion may not be a reliable indicator. People throughout the Middle East, by and large, speak Arabic and follow Islam; but I venture to say that if one were to lump Iranians in the same category as Saudis, or lump Egyptians together with Turks, the individuals involved would have a lot to say about it, and none of it very nice!

    It is all too easy to view long dead and vanished peoples in a static, immobile sort of way: as if nothing in their world ever changed, or mutated. But the one thing our own lives should teach us is that change is inevitable, and mutation is normal; and what is true for us was true in the past as well. What do researchers do to avoid looking at an ancient people as if they were merely specimens under a microscope? Or do they even attempt to avoid it?


    NEXT: Nation Building 1800 BC - Forget it!
    PREV: Excellent, I'll take a look!
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff