Welcome
Aedes Divi Iulii: Julius Caesar and His Times
For discussion of the life of Gaius Julius Caesar, 100-44 BC, and Rome in his time.

The Gallic Wars to the Rubicon (2 threads, 174 posts)
    De Bello Gallico (131 posts)
    Historical Thread

    For discussion of Caesar's masterwork of propoganda and history, "The Gallic Wars," and the campaigns it describes. ...
    25 Members have made 131 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: What If
    Prev: Caesar in Illyricum, and the BG
    About the objectivity thing
    Heraklia_teal.gif
    Author: * Heraklia Aelius - 34 Posts on this thread out of 7,266 Posts sitewide.
    Date: May 6, 2006 - 11:20

    LOL - it's such a truism that Caesar wrote all of this as propaganda, but I was reading elsewhere about that. The summary I got was - Sir Ronald Syme, writing his massive The Roman Revolution in the '30's, did what any great writer would do - set the discussion in terms of realities re-learned in his own time. Hence, all the implicit comparisons with warlords like Hitler and Mussolini and Stalin . . . and other, lesser writers just took that and ran with it. Including the notion that some things were all propaganda . . . Augustus' relations with writers like Livy and Horace, Caesar presenting himself best foot forward in the Commentaries, etc., etc.

    Whereas it was really all much more subtle than that.

    I tend to agree. I think the BG is one of the great classic resources of ancient history, like the Parthenon. Yes, he was writing to impress the Senate - but the clarity and beauty of language, the ability to stand back and summarize complex actions, to highlight deep-seated conflicts, the lively interest in cultural phenomena, the constant ability to praise associates - all say a lot more about Caesar than just mere self-serving.


    NEXT: What If
    PREV: Caesar in Illyricum, and the BG
iMac


Copyright 2002-2007 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff