LOL - this is so well done, I went back from Clue # 1 and re-read them ALL, making notes of dogs that "didn't bark in the night." I THINK I've got a theory about the killer now, but there are still some anomalies . . . those darned fish! Can't wait for clue # 8 - perhaps that will resolve my doubts.

*goes back over her lists of whodunnit and whocouldn'thavedunnit and whomighthavedunnit.*

I still feel I'm missing a detail . . . ack!