Welcome
Hugrunar - The World of the Vikings
A group for the discussion of all aspects of the culture of the Vikings - their wars, voyages, art, literature, language and legacy. Hugrunar means 'Thought Runes' and encompasses discussion of the Viking Age from the Fifth to the Eleventh Centuries.

The Mead of Poetry - Viking Literature and Art (3 threads, 66 posts)
    The Word Hoard - Viking Poetry and Sagas (27 posts)
    Historical Thread

    Discussion of the rich skaldic poetic tradition of the Vikings and of the great sagas which celebrated the achievements of Viking warriors and kings. ...
    10 Members have made 25 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: I think I agree
    Prev: Re:Re Egil
    Sagas, Romantic or Historical
    suthoohelm.jpg
    Author: * Theodric Scylding - 1 Post on this thread out of 85 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Dec 10, 2002 - 12:57

    "Do the sagas really relfect what was happening in tenth and eleventh century Iceland, or are they just a twelfth century view of what was happening- mybe romanticised for an audience."

    Interesting question, Londinius. And one that I am not sure can be answered satisfactorily. My own thought is that some of the sagas are probably very historically accurate, drawing upon oral tradition and maybe even previously written material. Of course, I also suspect that even in the historically accurate sagas there is some artistic licence, a bit of romanticising what actually happened, to keep the audience entertained. Too, there does seem to have been several different types of sagas. There are the historical sagas, such as Egil, where they purport to tell the life of a man who actually lived and that appear to be historically accurate. Then there are sagas that are little more than romantic fiction. Friðbjófs Saga is a prime example of this.

    Anyhow, do the sagas reflect what was happening in tenth and eleventh century Iceland or are they romaticised for an audience? I think a little bit of both in most cases!


    NEXT: I think I agree
    PREV: Re:Re Egil
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff