The Symposion Series (- threads, 1059 posts)
    PERSIAN FIRE by Tom Holland (55 posts)
    Historical Thread 2 Featured November 20 , 2005

    ...
    9 Members have made 46 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: Thank you all
    Prev: Thx Tom & Heraklia
    The Persian military
    th_gs.gif
    Author: * Tom Holland Scriptor - 15 Posts on this thread out of 40 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Nov 24, 2005 - 14:35

    It is true that the Persians appeared, to Greek eyes, woefully under-armoured. When Herodotus calls them 'gymnetes', he doesn't mean that they were LITERALLY naked - just that in comparison to a Greek hoplite, they might as well have been. In reality, not only did the Persians indeed wear quilted tunics, but many seem to have worn corslets of fish scales - although these may have been confined to the commanders (remember Mardonius' cavalry commander at Plataea). Conversely, to Persian eyes, Greek armies were hilarious cumbersome, easy pickings for their incredibly proficient and mobile cavalry. Don't forget that until Marathon, no Greek army had ever inflicted defeat upon the Persians. Even at Marathon, the key to the Athenian victory appears to have been the absence of the cavalry. Only at Plataea did the Greeks manage to inflict a defeat upon the horsemen of the enemy.

    As for the Immortals, yes, the Greeks called the elite of the royal guard the 'melophoroi' - 'the apple bearers'. The dispute about the their more famous title comes from a possible confusion over the Persian word for 'immortal' ('anausa') and the word for 'attendant' ('anusiya'). Most scholars nowadays seem to believe that Herodotus got it right, but there's no way of knowing for sure, of course.


    NEXT: Thank you all
    PREV: Thx Tom & Heraklia
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff