with being an optimist, cock-eyed or not. One could argue successfully that the entire trilogy is Tolkien's expression of optimism. That Good ultimately triumphs no matter how powerful the Evil.

As for the ultimate redemption, or damnation, of the Nazgul, that would be decided by the mythos of their world. Perhaps an argument could be made on their behalf and an opportunity presented for them to redeem their souls. However, and perhaps my pessimism influences my thinking on this point, having been controlled by the Ring and by Sauron for so long a time, they'd be unwilling, or unable, to accept any such opportunity. This would, of course, condemn them to eternal damnation.

I'm sure there are others out there who have their own thoughts regarding the ultimate fate of the Nazgul, Sauron, and Saruman. Share your thoughts with us.