Welcome
Arturus Rex
Where the Legend is to Become Reality.

The Real King Arthur (2 threads, 154 posts)
    Myth or Reality? (81 posts)
    Social Thread

    King or Myth? ...
    21 Members have made 79 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: chapter thirteen summary
    Prev: chapter eleven summary
    chapter twelve summary
    Arran's Photos.jpg
    Author: * Walensis Volcae - 25 Posts on this thread out of 64 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Jun 2, 2004 - 10:18

    * We have endeavoured to establish who King Arthur really was. The most plausible contender is a prince of Gwynedd, who unified the nationalist and imperialist factions of late fifth-century Britain.

    1. That the Britons were stronger and more united by the last decade of the fifth century is not only shown in Gildas, Bede and the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, but is also reflected in archaeology. For example, there are sophisticated fortifications constructed by the British at this time all across the East of Britain. Although this suggests a strong and determined leader, no surviving document for the next three centuries names him. Nennius' Historia Brittonum is the first to do so, telling us that the leaders name was Arthur.

    2. Of the British kingdoms free from Anglo-Saxon occupation, only five were sufficiently strong to have been Arthur's power base: Gwynedd in North Wales, Dyfed and Gwent in South Wales, Dumnonia in South-West England, and Powys in the West Midlands and Central Wales. The evidence to determine the most powerful of these kingdoms derives from Gildas. When he was writing, some fifty years after the battle of Badon, the most powerful kingdom was Gwynedd. This, coupled with Ambrosius' connection with the area before Arthur, means that Gwynedd must have been a leading power throughout the era, making it a strong contender for Arthur's original kingdom.

    3. Further evidence for Gwynedd being Arthur's kingdom comes from Geoffrey of Monmouth, when he names Arthur's father as Uther Pendragon. From the Welsh, the name means the 'terrible head dragon'. During the mid-fifth century, the rulers of Gwynedd had adopted the symbol of the red dragon as their emblem, and in Dark Age Welsh poetry the kings of Gwynedd are often referred to as the 'dragons of Britain', or the 'head dragons'. When Gildas addresses Maglocunus, the king of Gwynedd, he calls him 'dragon of the island'. If Uther Pendragon really was Arthur's father, then Arthur would appear to have been the son of the King of Gwynedd.

    fire.gif


    4. Nennius seems to imply that Arthur was not a native Briton. If he was, why does Nennius not simply say that Arthur 'led the British kings', instead of saying that 'he fought with the British'. Nennius appears to be drawing attention to some peculiarity. Could this imply that Arthur was a foreign king? This possibility draws us once again to the kingdom of Gwynedd. The kings who ruled this area do not appear to have been Britons at all. Both Nennius and the Annales Cambriae say that the kings Gwynedd descended from Cunedda, a warrior from the Scottish district of Manau Guotodin.

    5. From the Annales Cambriae and Nennius we can deduce that Cunedda was Maglocunus' great-grandfather, who was invited by the people of Gwynedd to protect them from Irish raiders. From the archaeological evidence, together with Gildas and Bede, the most likely period for this to have occurred was about 460. Since this is the time that Ambrosius made his bid for power, it is possible that Cunedda also helped him overthrow the Vortigern family.

    6. Since the genealogies attached to the Annales record Cunedda's son, Enniaun Girt, becoming king of Gwynedd after Cunedda's death, it seems that the Cunedda family assumed control of the kingdom sometime during or shortly after the Ambrosius period. Given that this period of Cunedda ascendancy lasted until the time of Gildas, it is very possible that Arthur was a member of this family.


    NEXT: chapter thirteen summary
    PREV: chapter eleven summary
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2011 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff