Welcome
Philos Sophia
For the study of ancient Greek philosophy.

Hellenistic Philosophies (5 threads, 35 posts)
    Propositional Logic (13 posts)
    Historical Thread

    For discussion on propositional logic advanced by the Stoics. ...
    3 Members have made 13 Posts here to date.
    Google
    AncientWorlds.net Web
    Next: logic and inference
    Prev: I think you understood the problem perfectly!
    Response
    germania2_rkh.gif
    Author: * Tabiya Atrahasis - 4 Posts on this thread out of 210 Posts sitewide.
    Date: Mar 5, 2003 - 16:09

    It is not so much an inference of A to B in modus ponens since an inference would be coming to a conclusion not directly supported by the facts. In the form of modus ponens the argument is only controlled in that

    If p then q. p, therefore q.

    This argument form is the simpliest in form and is only valid for that condition. Granted children pick up on it easily enough for

    If they behave they can go out and play. They behaved, therefore they can go out and play.

    One could say that basic logic in this form is "Childs play".

    Now, Modus tollens is based on inference as a whole line of events can cause the argument to be valid like you mentioned. Since these events are not addressed directly the argument for is valid. We look for examples disproving it, none of which are addressed in the conditions so they of no consequence.

    If p then q. Not q, therefore not p.

    The argument for is simply but it does not establish a definitive cause and effect for validity.


    NEXT: logic and inference
    PREV: I think you understood the problem perfectly!
Rome - Rome, Season 1 - The Stolen Eagle


Copyright 2002-2008 AncientWorlds LLC | Code of Conduct and Terms of Service | Contact Us! | The AncientWorlds Staff